French Path Canada › Writing graders compared

Public test · run on November 8, 2026

The same text, sent to the free TCF Canada writing graders

On November 8, 2026, the same text with 7 planted mistakes went to the free writing graders of 10 sites, ours included: here is what each one found.

Four sites returned a correction, one of them with a free account. Five have no free grader, one was not responding.

We are one of the sites tested: our grader takes the same test, under the same rules. Run the test yourself: the full text is below, paste it into any grader.

The results

The 7 mistakes in the text, found or not by the free grader of each site tested, on November 8, 2026
Mistake or measure formation-tcfcanada.comfree account frenchpathcanada.comours tcfcanadacoach.comfree preview nclcfrench.comno account
F1nous sommes allé → allés found found found not found
F2il y a trois ans → depuis trois ans not found found not visible in the free preview not found
F3de les joindre → de me joindre à eux found not found not visible in the free preview not found
F4de les traditions → des traditions found found found not found
F5très chaleureux → très chaleureuse found found not visible in the free preview not found
F6si j’aurais su → si j’avais su found found not visible in the free preview not found
F7que la mairie organisera → organise found found not visible in the free preview not found
Mistakes found 6 of 7 (best figure in the row) 6 of 7 (best figure in the row) 2 of 7visible 0 of 7
Correct form 6 of 7 (best figure in the row) 6 of 7 (best figure in the row) 2 of 7visible 0 of 7
Rule stated 1 of 7 5 of 7 (best figure in the row) 2 of 7visible 0 of 7
False corrections 0 (best figure in the row) 1 0visible (best figure in the row) 0 (best figure in the row)
Score shown 0/20, A1 none NCLC 6, 7/20 9/20, NCLC 6
No account nofree account yes yes yes
Time 32 s 7 s, then 18 s 40 s 51 s at most

foundnot foundnot visible in the free preview (the rest is in the paid report)the best figure in the row, ties included

The order: by mistakes found, then by false corrections (fewest first). Our column is coloured, not put first.

False correction: a correct passage flagged as a mistake, or a correction that makes the passage wrong. Ours: “des joindre”, suggested for F3.

Try a text in our grader
The 7 planted mistakes, and the correct formThe rule for each one, and the trap sentence
  1. F1nous sommes allé → nous sommes allésWith être, the past participle agrees with the subject: “ma femme et moi” is masculine plural.
  2. F2J’habite ici il y a trois ans → J’habite ici depuis trois ansA duration that is still going on takes “depuis”.
  3. F3ils m’ont demandé de les joindre → de me joindre à eux“Joindre quelqu’un” means to contact someone. Joining a group is “se joindre à”.
  4. F4parlé de les traditions → parlé des traditions“De” and “les” contract into “des”.
  5. F5l’ambiance était très chaleureux → très chaleureuseThe adjective agrees with “ambiance”, a feminine noun.
  6. F6Si j’aurais su → Si j’avais suAfter a “si” that sets a condition, never the conditional.
  7. F7il faut que la mairie organisera → il faut que la mairie organise“Il faut que” takes the subjunctive.
  8. PAprès que les musiciens sont partis, correct“Après que” takes the indicative. A grader that asks for “soient partis” flags a mistake that is not one. No grader flagged it in what it shows for free.
Read the text we sentA task 2 of about 140 words, to paste into any grader

The topic, task 2, as candidates report it: « Vous avez récemment assisté à une fête de quartier entre voisins. Sur votre blog, racontez votre expérience et expliquez pourquoi vous avez aimé cet événement. » (You recently went to a neighbourhood party. On your blog, tell how it went and explain why you liked it.) 120 to 150 words. The topic in detail

Samedi dernier, ma femme et moi, nous sommes allé à la fête des voisins de notre rue. J’habite ici il y a trois ans, mais je n’avais jamais participé. Quand nous sommes arrivés, il y avait déjà beaucoup de monde : des familles, des voisins âgés et même le maire. Des voisins préparaient des plats de leur pays et ils m’ont demandé de les joindre. J’ai parlé longtemps de les traditions de mon pays avec une dame très gentille. Après que les musiciens sont partis, nous avons rangé les tables tous ensemble.

J’ai aimé cette fête pour deux raisons. D’abord, l’ambiance était très chaleureux. Ensuite, j’ai enfin fait connaissance avec mes voisins. Si j’aurais su que c’était si agréable, je serais venu avant. L’année prochaine, il faut que la mairie organisera plus de jeux pour les enfants. Venez nombreux !

About 140 words · written by us for this test

Site by site

What each grader wrote, quoted as is (in French when the site answered in French, with a translation), with the screenshot. Our card reads like the others: our misses are written out plainly.

formation-tcfcanada.com6 of 7, 0 false corrections

Tested with a free account (3 free tries). Imposed topic, the closest task 2: « Vous avez assisté à une fête de famille. Envoyez un message à vos amis pour leur raconter cette fête et expliquez ce que vous avez le plus apprécié. » (A family party, told to your friends.) The simulator runs all three tasks; only task 2 was filled in.

Mistakes listed: « nous sommes allés », « rejoindre », « des traditions », « l’ambiance était très chaleureuse », « Si j’avais su… », then « Après « il faut que », employer le subjonctif » (after “il faut que”, use the subjunctive). F2 not flagged. The rule is stated only for F7.

On the topic: « La consigne porte sur une fête de famille, alors que la réponse raconte une fête de voisins. Ce décalage avec le sujet entraîne une note éliminatoire. » (The task is about a family party, the answer tells a neighbours’ party: this off-topic answer gets an eliminating score.) Task 2: « 0/20 », « A1 ». It also asks for « un titre et l’ouverture « Chers lecteurs, » » (a title and the opening “Dear readers,”): not counted as a false correction, since it is not a language mistake. Overall score « 0/20 »: two tasks left empty.

frenchpathcanada.comours6 of 7, 1 false correction

Two stages on the same page, each sent once: the grader, then the “Relecture approfondie” (in-depth review). The grader flags F1, F4, F5, F6 and F7; the review adds F2.

Our misses. F3 not flagged: “de les joindre” is not caught as a calque of English. The grader even suggests “des joindre”, with “Contraction obligatoire” (mandatory contraction), shown as certain and ticked by default: that is our false correction. F4, the real contraction, is found but marked “à vérifier” (to check). For F1, the rule given is the adjective agreement rule, not the one for the participle with être. Nothing is said about staying on topic.

Shown: « Fautes relevées 6 », « 5 cochées », « Grille tenue 3/4 », « 138 mots, dans la fourchette demandée (120 à 150). » (6 mistakes found, 5 ticked, criteria met 3/4, 138 words, within the range.)

tcfcanadacoach.com2 of 7 visible, 0 false corrections visible

The free preview shows « Les 2 corrections les plus importantes » (the 2 most important corrections): F1 and F4, with the correct form. It announces 7 more corrections in the full report, which is paid (from US$9.90): we do not know which ones, nor whether the trap sentence is among them.

For F4, the rule talks about « partitif « des » » (partitive “des”); it is the contracted article (de + les). A borderline case, counted in the site’s favour.

Shown: « NCLC 6 », « CECR B1 · Note estimée 7/20 », « Nombre de mots : 138 (120–150) ». Free topic: we pasted our own task.

nclcfrench.com0 of 7, 0 false corrections

Imposed topic, their free task 2: « Vous avez assisté récemment à une pièce de théâtre dans votre ville. » (A play you saw in your town.) Our text tells a party: it is off topic.

Shown: « 9 / 20 », “About NCLC 6 on this task · CEFR B1”, “Rough estimate”, then “AI scoring was unavailable, so this score is a rough estimate based on the length of your answers only.” No mistake flagged.

On the task: “Strength · You answered the task.” and “To improve · Aim for 120–150 words.”, for a text of 138 words by their own counter.

Not tested on November 8: 6 sitesFive with no free grader, one unreachable: the reason and the screenshot for each
reussir-tcfcanada.comNo free grader: paid simulator, account required

The link « Accéder à mon espace Simulateur TCF Canada » (go to my simulator space) leads to expressiontcf.com, which asks you to log in. Signing up asks for last name, first name, email, password, phone number and a plan. The writing and speaking simulator is sold separately: US$14.99, 29.99 or 49.99 for 5, 15 or 30 uses (prices checked on November 7). No free trial found.

freetcf.comNo free grader: correction reserved for the Pro plan

Tested with a free account. The text can be pasted into their task 2 (« Vous avez participé à une brocante… », a flea market), but the « Corriger » (correct) button opens: « La correction IA est réservée à Pro » (AI correction is reserved for Pro), with « Choisir Pro · 19,99 CAD/mois » (CA$19.99 a month).

examen-tcfcanada.comUnreachable: the site showed no page during the test

On November 8, from 3:33 to 3:41 a.m. (Eastern time), the site returned no page: six tries, connection timed out. No screenshot possible. To be redone at the next test.

tcfprep.caNo free grader: no text box

No grader on the site. Their FAQ, on the writing test: “While we don’t provide direct feedback, reviewing sample questions and answers can help”. The box on the screenshot was added by us.

tcfcad.comNo free grader: the grader address leads to the price page

The address of the writing grader (« Correcteur Expression Écrite IA ») leads to the price page. « Expression écrite illimitée » (unlimited writing) is listed as a bonus of the packs, from US$9.99.

tcfmentor.comNo free grader: free account, no text box

Tested with a free account. The topics of the month say « Rédigez votre texte, soumettez-le pour correction » (write your text, submit it for correction), but the page has no text box and no send button, logged in or not. The paid packs advertise « Corrections Détaillées » (detailed corrections).

How we tested

Our grid and our checks are licensed under CC BY 4.0: you can reuse them by crediting French Path Canada. The names and content of the tools compared belong to their owners.

The full protocol (in French) · The test in detail, site by site (in French)

The rules of the test, and what we recordOne submission per site, the first result published, nothing paid
  • The same text, character for character, pasted without edits. If the site imposes its own topics, we take the closest task 2 and say so.
  • The free grader only, no payment at all. If a free account is required, we say so; when we create one, we say that too.
  • One submission per site and per test. The first result is published, no second try.
  • We quote what the grader wrote. We do not rate any site.
  • For each site we record: the mistakes found out of 7, the correct form and the rule stated, the false corrections, the score or level shown (quoted word for word), what it says about the topic and the word count, the access and the waiting time.
  • A site with no free grader, or that asks for payment to correct, stays in the list with the reason and the date we checked.
  • A new test every month. Past tests stay visible, with their date.

Why our grader gives no score

A score that rises with the length of a text reassures you, then makes you fail. We would rather show you every mistake with its correct form, and what is missing for CLB 7.

Right of reply

You run one of these sites and think the test is unfair, or a line is wrong? Write to bonjour@frenchpathcanada.com. Your reply is published here, in full, within a week. A recording error is corrected, with the date of the correction.

Replies received: none so far.

The tests, month by month

The same text, to the same sites. Next test on December 8, 2026.